The cookie bonster
Custom Ordered Baked Goods. Let us make your day a little sweeter!
The cookie bonster
Custom Ordered Baked Goods. Let us make your day a little sweeter!
Welcome
From cookies to decadent cakes, we're here to add a little sweetness to your life. All of our indulgences are handmade for the cookie-rookie to the cake-connoisseur.
Let us know how we can custom bake your next gift or for your special occasion.
- Bonnie Fertell
Samples you can almost taste
Bake it 'till you make it
Custom Baking Done Right
All of our creations use the best ingredients with a mind towards sustainability and local sourcing. We custom bake each order for our customers and though we try our best to prevent cross contamination, we are not an allergy-free bakery.
sample Pricing
Cookies
Minimum order quantity: 6
Toffee chocolate chunk
20
Festive funfetti
30
Frosted sugar cookie
27
Bourbon pecan chocolate chip
18
Snickerdoodle
12
Salted caramel and chocolate pretzel bark
28
One batch is approximately 40 pieces
Brownies
Size: 8" x 8" (four 4" x 4" pieces)
Fudge brownie with cookie butter icing
25
Salted caramel brownie
25
Toffee chocolate chip blondie
20
Toffee chocolate chip blondie with buttercream
25
Pecan pie brownie with caramel drizzle
28
Heart patchwork fudge brownie with buttercream
25
Cupcakes
Minimum order quantity: 6
Lemon with raspberry buttercream
21
3.50 each
Mudslide
21
3.50 each
Oreo buttercream
21
3.50 each
Vanilla buttercream
18
3.00 each
The Jar Collection
Minimum order quantity: 6
Vanilla or chocolate cupcake jars
48
8.00 each
Iced brownie jars
48
8.00 each
Layered Cakes
Available in 6-, 8- and 9-inches. Sample pricing for 9-inch below.
Triple chocolate cheesecake
49
Chocolate peanut butter cheese cake
49
Mudslide cake
52
Custom cakes
Upon Request
We are happy to provide quantity pricing and fulfill custom requests.
Sweet Feedback!
Ashley R.
Ashley R.
Ashley R.
I absolutely recommend Bonnie. Everything she makes is absolutely delicious! I’ve personally had the privilege of consuming her cupcakes, cake, blondies, cookies and brownies and they are hands down TOP NOTCH. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
Matt H.
Ashley R.
Ashley R.
I've had the pleasure of enjoying several of Bonnie's wonderful creations... and have yet to be disappointed! She absolutely puts her heart into every recipe... and it shows.
You'll be pleasantly surprised!
Rachel H.
Ashley R.
Michael H.
Bonnie does incredible work! Our twin boys are huge Minecraft fans & she made them an amazing cake for their 8th birthday. She nailed the colors & design and was able to craft a yummy choc chip cake.
Michael H.
Michael H.
Michael H.
Everything Bonnie makes is absolutely amazing. Get her a brick and mortar immediately I will spend my entire paycheck here.
Rosita O.
Michael H.
Rosita O.
The Cookie Bonster really delivered and went the extra mile to make my vision for a birthday cake for my son! I requested a triple-layer chocolate cake with peanut butter icing so that we could decorate it to resemble an Amazon package. The cake was delicious and everyone thoroughly enjoyed it!
Nate M.
Michael H.
Rosita O.
When I lived back east I’ve had cookies and cakes Bonnie has prepared and they have been EXQUISITE. Keep up the good work and GREAT desserts.
Call or Email
The Cookie Bonster
64 E. Uwchlan Avenue, #230
Exton, PA 19341
This website uses (and makes) cookies.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.